Uncomfortable

We’ve had a lot of protests in the U.S. lately.  A few have erupted into violence with tragic consequences.  Many more have been peaceful gatherings over critical issues like healthcare, women’s rights and equality, to name a few.  And now peaceful protest has broken out on the sidelines of NFL games.  After so many demonstrations, some folks (not the protesters!) are saying they’re exhausted by all the protests.  It’s all making them very uncomfortable – particularly this one.

Protests are supposed to make you uncomfortable – no matter which side of the disputed issue you support.  That is the point.  The peaceful protests against segregation in the 60’s made a lot of people very uncomfortable.  They also precipitated at least part of the change sought.  Likewise, the college sit-ins during the Vietnam war upset many – not just the parents of the protesters.  Again, they had a significant effect on the path out of that war.  And let’s not forget the very recent protests regarding pending legislation to break the Affordable Care Act.  This time, it took 3 rounds of demonstrations to drive the point home to senators.  It worked – for now.  In each case, the venues were chosen to maximize discomfort for those who need to see the other side of the story.  Demonstrating for LGBTQ rights in a gay bar won’t change a lot of hearts and minds.  The sideline of a Sunday NFL game, on the other hand, is a perfect choice to bring attention to systemic oppression of African-Americans.

The NFL protests are facing additional headwinds.  First, the teams are corporations.  Companies have broad latitude on workplace rules and many do not allow protests of any form.  But the antebellum optics of 16 white owners shutting down protests by black players (who make up 75% of their workforce) are cringe-worthy.  The other new twist is Dear Leader’s hijacking of the protest, saying it is disrespecting THE FLAG.  Now uncomfortable people can just say “flag” so they can avoid saying “black.”

But the issue is black lives, not red, white, and blue.  Frankly, taking a knee seems very respectful of both anthem and flag.  It is beautiful in its simplicity:  we love this country, but systemic oppression must be addressed.  The players thought about sitting during the anthem, but decided that taking a knee was more respectful to the flag, the song, and the military.

The problem for the league is that the people who should be most uncomfortable are burning their NFL merchandise.  It’s there every Sunday and they are “exhausted” by opening kickoff.  They can turn off the Charlottesville protests.  But this is more complicated.  It requires fast-forwarding past the pre-game stuff straight to the kickoff.  Now the NFL has to hold a fire sale  on those commercial slots, and is running scared about their advertisers and viewership.  So they’re going to vote on a corporate rule to ban this activity.  Craven?  A little.  Greedy?  A lot.

Uncomfortable yet?

Of the People

I’ve heard some disturbing survey results regarding democracy lately.  A bunch of poll statistics were released from something sounding official and unbiased that indicated support for democracy is declining in the U.S.  The figures for young people were even more disappointing. I was saddened and dismayed.  We literally wrote the book on democratic government, and now we think maybe it’s not worth the trouble.

This shouldn’t be a surprise.  We only need look at voter turnout.  It was somewhere around 58% in 2016, a presidential year.  In 2014, when we totally repopulated the House and a third of the Senate, it was at 36%.  Other countries – not just the “developed” ones, have turnouts in the 80% – 90% range.  One person, one vote is the basis of any democracy.  We are the people who fund our government and are bound by its dictates.  This is our one and only chance to shape it as we, the people, see fit.  We are failing.  Voter restrictions are real, and have a dramatic outcome on elections. Our indifference, however has profound results as well.

Abraham Lincoln said we seek a government “of the people, by the people and for the people.”  Today, we grouse about how badly Washington is at the “for the people” part, yet we ignore the “of…” and “by…” bits.  The word democracy has its root in the Greek word “demos” – the people.  It implies that we need to be involved in some way.  When people who can, don’t vote, they are shirking a primary responsibility of citizens.

I’m not a fan of the “if you don’t vote, you can’t complain” argument.  We’re all going to complain.  It is our nature.  But if you don’t vote, you’ve let us all down.  You have withheld your best from us:  your opinions, your views on issues, and your hard spots.  We are all worse as a result.  This goes double for those small-time local elections that nobody cares about.  In reality, these are the choices that touch us all most closely.  These people decide which neighborhoods get sewers when, which streets will get plowed in winter, and what our kids are taught in school.  These are also the farm teams for the big players:  state and federal representatives.  While you may think your vote is worthless in the national races because you live in a staunchly red/blue state, you still have a huge impact on who makes decisions in your city or school district.

Our responsibility as citizens of a democratic republic doesn’t end there.  An uninformed vote is not worthless.  It is often harmful, succumbing to the candidate with the best sound bites and the most press.  It reduces choices to a game of barroom darts at closing time.  If we can take the time to know who has the most rushing yards in the NFL, or who’s screwing whom in Real Housewives, we can find the time to understand where the candidates stand on things that mean the most to each of us every day.  In less time than it takes google a Thai restaurant that delivers, we could understand of how that school board nominee will vote on what our eighth grader will learn.

Democracy requires work, but it’s not heavy lifting.  The task is to make a good choice, nothing more.  It requires some education away from what mainstream media will feed us.  There are a lot of sources out there that span the political spectrum.  We should even read a few that pose views far from our own.  These are human voices.  We’re all better off if we at least listen.  Listening is not condoning.

“…of the people, by the people…” We need to hold up our end of the deal, folks.  If we fail to make good choices – or any choices at all – we will lose the ability to ever do so again.  Those who take over will legislate it out of existence, to be supplanted by decree, corruption and repression.  Democracy is very threatening to despots. They will swoop in, given the chance.  Even in the USA.  Sorry folks, we have no special immunity.

A Simple Thing I Know and Often Forget

I learned about something new today:  the myth of “redemptive violence.”  In effect, when someone does something to offend or anger me, I have the right to be enraged and inflict violence on them, and that is key to my success.  The more I thought about it, the myth became apparent.  Anger is a hungry beast that has to keep eating.  It is an animal that eats its own tail and thence becomes bigger and hungrier.  Sometimes it doesn’t stop until someone is dead.  Something else has to stop it from eating.  Maybe it’s a gentle teacher on a playground breaking up a fight, or that friend who pulled me aside and told me to chill.  Violence doesn’t redeem.  But it sure makes me feel powerful in the moment.  When it’s in full, fiery bloom, we know that we can wreak all kinds of damage.  We can end or ruin many people’s lives right then and there.  We are gods unto ourselves – passing judgment and meting out punishment as we please.

After all the killing in the last month, I wonder if there’s any way out.  Are we going to eat ourselves up painfully until society goes to hell?  There has to be an answer.  Well, I also learned today just how simple the answer is, and that I’ve known it since I was born.  It’s called love.  Pure and simple.  I need to love my neighbor – who just happens to be everybody.  But it’s as simple as it is hard.  Of course, in addition to puppies, babies, my wife and my family, I have to love blacks, gays, Jews, and Muslims.  But does this mean that I have to love the guy who just cut me off in his 4×4 just to prove his manhood?  Or the selfish woman who took all the samples off the tray in Costco?  Yes, I do.  Yet I still often forget the simple answer.  The notion that I have to put my self aside and recognize that for all their differences, quirks, and downright idiocy, these people are made of the same stuff as me.  They live, they die, they have families, happy times and sorrow just like me.  But that’s harder than it sounds, and it already  sounds pretty tough.

Still, those are the easy ones.  What about those who hate?  What about all those recent killers, those twisted and sick people who just want to hurt everybody or a select few?  Seriously?  I have to love THEM?  Yeah, I think that’s the idea.  I struggle with that a lot. It feels like I’m handing victory to an enemy who wronged me.  But love doesn’t mean giving in or giving up or not defending myself or my family.  It does mean that the beast of rage and anger shouldn’t control my actions – or my thoughts, and that I recognize them as human beings.  I was taught to believe that God loves each and every one of us.  Am I so perfect that I can choose differently?

A wise preacher once related it this way:  many of us have been taught that God is love.  When we contemplate evil or Satan, we think the opposite – it’s all about hate.  But this man put a different spin on it.  Evil is selective love.  I will only love you if you’re rich or white or straight.  I will only love you if you stay in your own lane or let me get mine first.  And then anger gets a chance to grow and eat me up.

I can’t count how many times I’ve forgotten this.

Remembrance

My daughter, Bonnie, went on a field trip to Washington DC when she was in middle school some years ago.  Part of the visit was to the Holocaust Museum which had recently opened.  She was so moved by what she saw that she composed a song, “Warsaw Polonaise,” shortly after returning, in memory of the people and the horrors they endured.  Years later, my wife and I went on a trip through Eastern Europe.  I remember that I was in the midst of a somewhat significant career setback.  Probably a routine thing these days, but it was a big depressing deal for me.

Then we visited the Auschwitz-Birkenau concentration camp.  I knew from the moment I walked through the gate that my problems were nothing.  Less than nothing.  A mere pothole on the road of life.  This was where evil flourished.  From the motto on the gate:  “Arbeit Macht Frei” (Work will set you free) to the “showers” and the ovens, I knew that this kind of terror should be swept away forever.  Tragically, it has not.  It recurs in ethnic cleansing, tyranny and civil wars.  It rejuvenates because evil is pernicious.  It grows because it’s always someone else’s problem.  It thrives because good people allow it to.

This video unites my daughter’s and my remembrances of this place and time.  I finished it about 10 years ago and put it aside.  It’s tough to watch once, but going over it hundreds of times in the editing process proved unbearable, so I had to let it go until now.  My apologies if it is difficult to watch, but evil is ugly and terror is ghastly yet we live side by side with them every day.

The Medium is the Message

Whether you agree with Marshall McLuhan’s assertions or not, it’s hard to look at American, or even global politics and not appreciate the effect of our news outlets.  We are bombarded – choose to be bombarded, by conservative/moderate/liberal spins on every word, nuance, and stutter that comes out of our politicians’ mouths.  We subscribe to alerts on our cell phones so we don’t miss anything, even when we’re in the restroom.  McLuhan probably didn’t see it at the time, but now it’s the immediacy of the information that shapes the message.

But what shapes the media?  Why is it that we only get a soundbite these days?  Quotes by all, regardless of party, are extracted, trimmed, cut and pasted into our news feeds.  The parts that grab our eyes and ears are broadcast, and context is stripped away.  These are supposed to be news organizations, but they only give us a fraction of what happened and none of the “why?”  I think the answer is competition.  Traditional channels like newspapers and network news struggle to stay in business against the onslaughts of blogs, Drudge Report, Huffington Post, Buzzfeed and all the rest.  Don’t get me wrong, the diversity could and should make us more informed, yet they stop short of giving us the whole message.

My particular frustration is the question not asked in mainstream tele-news.   Here’s how that unfolds:  a situation of real controversy or importance emerges.  The target or proponent is interviewed by (insert your favorite news organization here).  The interviewer asks “hard-hitting” questions.  The guest responds with a lie, half truth, or context-free answer.  It is clear to everyone that they have dodged the question.  The next question dangles in the air:  “so let me ask again,” “so just why did you do that?,” or “did you think about those affected by your decision?” but it falls, unasked.   And we are left to either believe the steaming hot BS that was just served up, or turn away in frustration.  Why?

I have a theory.   I’ll pick on the Sunday news shows – all of them – as an example.  Say 5 outlets want to interview this person.  They’ve all talked before and it’s been congenial.  “Come back and talk to us soon,” is often the parting line.  But what happens if one of the interviewers is polite but persistent in getting a real, complete answer to the question?  They might get kudos for great journalism, but their employers will never, ever get to interview that person again, or anyone close to them.  That news outlet is effectively blacklisted by the target.  And they can do this because there are 4 other news  programs licking their chops at the prospect of access to this person.  By doing their job responsibly, they are unable to do so in the future.  By colluding, consciously or not, with the interviewee, they live to broadcast again.

I wish I had a simple answer to this one.  It’s important because this is how many shape their decisions about voting.  Just like all our voting problems, this comes down to each and every one of us.  In order to be an informed voter (read:  be in a position for your vote to make a real difference) we need to demand that our newspeople ask the next question.  And the next.  And the one after that.  Or we should flock to those that will.

Life, Love, and Christmas Dinner

I remember the first big holiday meal we cooked in our own house for guests.  Linda and I suddenly felt like real adults.  Sure, having kids forces you to grow up fast.  But we were quite amazed that we could get a roast, mashed potatoes, and Yorkshire pudding on the table at the same time without burning down the house or poisoning anyone.

I love to cook.  Mincing rosemary and fussing over a roast is my meditation. Kitchen tag-teaming with my wife and daughter is a bonding experience.  The guttural sounds of guests too busy chewing to talk is our acclamation.  While we clean up as we go, the mess piles inexorably behind.  A greasy cutting board and crystal caked with eggnog trail in my wake.  But, it’s done.  Five hours of cooking reduced to bones in 15 minutes.  Life is good.

Now,  I’ve cleared the blast radius.  Others are performing triage on the mashed potato stickies and fine china.  I’m outta there. This escape used to make me feel guilty.  Then my son moved in temporarily with his fiancée to pause between houses.  Tonight he has inherited these uglies.  He’s very good at cleaning.  Mandy has trained him well.   Now, I can see the true circle of life coming to fruition before my eyes.  Then:  we cleaned up, picked up, and propped up.  Now:  they are cleaning up and picking up.  They were remarkable propping up my 91-year old mother-in-law.

Soon, Sean and Mandy will do one of these in their new house.  I know that the world today has forced them to grow up faster than we did.  But I wonder if they’ll experience that same grown-up feeling when it all hits the table.

I suppose I’ll be doing the dishes that night.

Juxtaposition

Hey, the Pope is here this week.  Did you hear?  Sounds like his crowds are just ‘yuuge.  He’s pretty much taken over all the networks.  They all run these hours-long shows with the same name:  “Pope Francis in America.”  Even Al-Jazeera.  But he’s talking so softly, and has that accent that can be difficult to understand.  Sometimes he insists on speaking Spanish.  How’s he going to compete in this time when we all shout at each other?

I have to admit, I was hoping he’d rip about 535 new ones when he addressed Congress.  But he didn’t.  Of course this gentle man would never do that.  Instead, he lifted them up.  He talked about inclusion and how we are all immigrants and life and the environment.  He told them they could do the job – that WE can do the job.  He didn’t call them out for all the times they punted on opportunities to do the right thing, to help people in need.  Even when he was directive about things like getting rid of the death penalty, his message was fundamentally Christian:  repentance and salvation.  He charged us all with our human obligation to help others.  Don’t keep score, just do it.

He’s still here, and a lot of us are basking in that Pope aura.  The crowds are testament to that.  I think we all needed a good dose of hope and joy.  Hold the cynicism, please.

 

I saw that Donald Trump had trouble filling a hotel ballroom yesterday.  He was booed today, too.

Them

We would all like to blame someone. We prefer that it be somebody else. It relieves pressure when things are going bad. They need fixing, not us. Perhaps it is part of our wiring as human beings because it is everywhere. Even petty arguments often start and end by trying to assign blame. In politics, it is poison.

This attitude allows us to avoid change, which is always difficult. It’s uncomfortable and requires a whole new set of habits. When group-think comes into play, it’s pretty safe to say that resistance to change is pretty thick. So we shift the blame to someone else: immigrants (legal and otherwise), African-Americans, Hispanics, Gays, or Jews. This has been a rallying cry for wild-eyed fanatics and cold, calculating despots alike. So many ascents to power were fueled by the pogroms and the corpses left behind. Hutu/Tutsi, Nazi/Jew, Serb/Bosniak, and so on. And when the dust settled, the winning populations were never better off. Nothing changed. They never solved the systemic problems. But the tyrant got power, and that was all that mattered to that “administration.”

Unless you are a Native American, you and your lineage were once “them.” They’ve all taken a turn in the barrel getting shot. Quakers, Irish, African Americans, Poles, the list is long. They were called out as the reason for hard times. The logic is structurally flawed. These people were almost always at the low end of the totem pole. They didn’t influence the decisions by leaders which brought about the crises. But at least the strident had someone to blame.

Now it’s Hispanics’ turn. As I listen to the leading Republican contender, he might make me believe that these people caused the great recession of 2008, the low wages that cripple hard-working people, and maybe even global warming. It’s quite convenient. But it allows the policies of the oligarchs, strong-arm lobbyers, billionaire election buyers and sycophants to continue unchecked. They can continue doing the same things to this country. It’s not their fault. It’s Them who caused it.

I love the diversity of this country. I’ve been to places in the world where ethnic purity was paramount, and even a trace of “others’” blood in your family tree was a source of shame. We are different, even if some of us can’t accept it. I’m not so sure about American exceptionalism, but if it exists, it’s because of how well we have (eventually) assimilated other cultures. My children are Irish-Italian-German-Nordic-Americans, and they are great.

We have problems in this country. Deporting millions will not change that, because they are not the problem. This policy will set us back by depriving us of the opportunity to embrace new cultures and weave their best into our fabric. Build your wall, if you will. Maybe it won’t be so awful. It might discourage people from making a trek through a desert that kills so many. But none of these will fix the problems caused by a privileged class that insulates themselves from reality and deflects blame so they can continue to exploit the rest of Us.

Back in the Saddle

It’s been over 9 month since my return from Africa.  I still remember parts of it like yesterday.  Given my short term memory performance, that’s not as impressive as it sounds.  It is great to be back home with my wife, my kids (although they live on opposite coasts), and all the familiar, comfortable surroundings.  I’ve held back from blogging for reasons I don’t completely understand.  I guess I just felt that folks might not be as interested in the thoughts and views from an old American as those from a stranger in a strange land.

I was musing about this a few days ago when my visiting future daughter-in-law (“pre-wife,” as my son calls her) set me straight.  “Stop worrying about whether those stories will interest the readers.  Write for yourself.”  She’s right, of course.  There’s a sort of creative bug that gets inside when you start something like this.  I’ve missed it for a while.  I’ve tried to fill it with music, with only mild success.  Just as there is prose trying to work its way out of me, there are songs as well.  I have a great time writing the lyrics and they are not awful.  Putting together the music to fit is another story.  Simple melodies, ok.  But what about the chorus, bridge, guitar solo, and on and on?  I’ve heard writers talk about the “deafening silence of blank paper.”  That hasn’t been such an issue for me.  But what about the “deafening silence of silence?”  Sometimes the notes won’t come.  Or they come and have nowhere to go except … away.

But let’s not plunge into the abyss of creative constipation here.  I was not raised in a particularly musical family, although my mom made sure that all of us had opportunities. I drifted away from clarinet, oboe and bassoon when I went to a high school without a music program.  But I’ve been blessed with 2 musically gifted children and a love for almost all genres of music.  There are a few exceptions that I won’t call out here, however.  Telling an aficionado that you don’t like their tunes is tantamount to starting a religious war.  I know this.  I am a longtime fan of Yes, which the rest of my family really can’t stand.  On long car trips, I am rationed.  I wait until Linda is asleep in the seat beside me before switching on “Perpetual Change.”  That lasts until I get carried away with the Steve Howe guitar solo, crank it up and then pay for it for about 15 miles.

Since I can’t sit still at all, music really gets me twitching.  Since it’s all about the bass, I’d thump along with that.  Eventually that turned into “air bass.”  You need to picture an air guitarist gyrating all over the air stage, ripping air riffs and generally looking dumb.  Off in the background is the air bassist standing in the shadows driving the non-existent beat, but not looking quite as dumb.  Well, my son got pretty sick of that and informed me that he was going to buy me a bass for Christmas about 10 years ago.  “Buy me a bass” meant accompanying me to Guitar Center, giving me great advice on which one to get, and then letting me pay for it.  Fair enough.  Since it was a “present” from Sean, there wasn’t much Linda could do about it (we’ll get into “parent points” in some future post).  She’s now great about putting up with my practicing at all hours.  However, she draws the line when I start to talk like a bass nerd, which is really boring. If you’ve read this far, you probably know what she means.

So, I’m back.  Yes, I’m using this blog as a kind of creative Metamucil.  Whatever works.  I’ve started dozens of posts that I shelved because I didn’t want to bore, vex, or otherwise offend folks.  If I do any of those to you in the coming posts, please blame Mandy.

They Say It’s Your Birthday

I have discovered how much I love birthdays.  By birthdays, I mean mine.  As I tell all those who get my wishes for their birthdays, “make everyone be nice to you.”  Tongue in cheek, but I think it’s at least a little bit deserved:  another punch in your ticket for trips around the sun.  Think of the miles you should get…

But I found that people really are nice to you on your birthday – if they know it’s your birthday.  There are a variety of ways to ensure this.  Basically they all equate to: just tell ‘em.  “Hey, 50ish years ago, you wouldn’t believe what my Mom did!”  That’ll get you a very nice sundae at Red Lobster (thanks, Rolando).  My family has described some of this behavior as the “Howdy Thing.”  I think that has something to do with me trying to be nice to tollbooth operators along the Autoroute in France.

Social media is evidently a great way to celebrate the blessed event.  But it means that everyone knows it.  The fact that I can get even a little of my medical information over the phone with just my name and date of birth gets the heebie-jeebies going.  I turned mine off – or so I thought.  Then a few months later, I got comments like “I didn’t know you were a New Year’s baby!!”  Thanks to all of you who sent nice wishes, but Facebook’s default setting took you astray.

Well, everyone was nice to me today.  I got phone calls from all my family.  They have a wide range of singing abilities.  Cards and presents.  What’s not to love?  A great night out with Linda and Helen.  Ate too much.

Happy Birthday to ya’

 

Credits/Apologies to The Beatles